This interesting, undated early sketch seems not to have been discussed
by previous commentators. The essence of the song is already
present, but there are significant differences and absences, for
example:
a) The song was originally notated throughout in 3/4
but most of the ink annotations show Mahler combining pairs of
bars into 6/4 bars to create an pattern of alternation of the two metres close
to that of the final version.
b) The first three 6/4 bars of the
song are absent: it starts at what is now b. 4, but without the
L.H. part.
c) The vocal line has a different
text underlay in the bars equivalent bb. 5–9 in the final
version:
Sketch |
Published version |
O Linden duft
Im Zimmer
stand |
Im Zimmer stand Ein
Zweig der Linde |
The conjectural dating offered here is based on the date of
Mahler's arrival in Maiernigg (HLGII,
358) and the date of the fair copy of the song (AV4,
dated 9 June 1901). This is a single
sheet used upside-down and back to front; at some date
it has been folded in half vertically. |